- Welcome Madison Avenue Presbyterian Church Presbyterian Church USA Presbytery of New York City 921 Madison Avenue New York, NY 10021 At 73rd Street on the Upper East Side of Manhattan (212) 288-8920 (voice) / (212) 249-1466 (fax) See the map and worship schedule and join us! Welcome! We hope that you will visit our church in person and make Madison Avenue Presbyterian your church home in New ...www.mapc.com