- The First Avenue Playhouse 123 First Avenue Atlantic Highlands, NJ 07716 (732) 291-7552 Located in beautiful Atlantic Highlands, the First Avenue Playhouse........ Featuring Dessert and Dinner Theatre! Sign-up now for the next 6 week session Price for 6 , 1 1/2 hour classes..$120.00 Time 4:30 to 6 pm Call 291-7552 for details and reservations Lighthouse Award '97 Dining Theatre Children's ...www.firstavenueplayhouse.com